Broken Appliance Repair Or Replace
Every homeowner faces this decision: the appliance is broken, the repair quote is in hand, and a shiny new model is on sale. Here is how professionals think through the repair-or-replace calculation to make the financially sound choice. Our vetted technicians cover refrigerator repair, washer repair, oven repair, and more — from $89 with a quality guarantee. Members save $50 on every repair visit.
The 50% Rule
The most widely used guideline is the 50% Rule: if the repair cost exceeds 50% of replacement cost, replacement is usually better value. For a $500 washer, a repair costing over $250 tips toward replacement.
The rule assumes normal appliance longevity — roughly 10 years for washers and dryers, 13 years for refrigerators, and 9 years for dishwashers. Adjust for your specific make and model.
Age Multiplier
Appliance age changes the calculus significantly. A five-year-old appliance with a $300 repair on a $700 unit warrants repair — it has years of service life ahead.
The same repair on a 12-year-old unit heading toward end-of-life may not. Combine the appliance age with the 50% rule for a more nuanced decision; technicians can usually estimate remaining service life during diagnosis.
Energy Efficiency Gains
Appliances manufactured more than eight years ago can consume 20–40% more energy than current Energy Star models.
If your monthly energy bill is high and the appliance is aging, replacement may pay for itself through energy savings over three to five years. Factor this into your total cost calculation alongside any utility rebates available in your state.
The Hidden Cost of Replacement
New appliances are not simply the sticker price. Add delivery ($25–$75), installation ($100–$200), removal of the old unit ($25–$75), and extended warranty purchases.
Repair is typically faster, cheaper in total, and keeps a known-good appliance running. Many repairs are completed same-day; replacement waits often run 1–3 weeks for delivery and installation slots.
Need a repair right now?
Same-day appointments available. Vetted technicians, upfront pricing from $89.
Book a RepairFrequently Asked Questions
Book Appliance Repair Near You
Also see: all appliance repair services · membership plans
Related Reading
Book home repair — from $89
Our team will be in touch to schedule your repair.